Multi-Role Debate Writing Workflow
Paste the following prompt into your AI chat to install this skill:
Install @user_e9af5021/critical-writing according to https://skillhub.cn/install/skillhub.md.
About this skill
Problem
Technical writing often stalls on vague briefs, self-satisfied first drafts, and feedback that is too polite to change the structure. critical-writing treats writing as an inspectable process instead of a one-shot generation task.
Workflow
- Intake: confirm the purpose, existing arguments, and desired output form, then ask the user to validate the plan.
- Critics: summon 2-3 distinct critics to identify issues, quote the draft, and note what should be preserved.
- Debate: force disagreement between critics so the revision is driven by conflict rather than agreement.
- Arbitration: separate consensus fixes from open conflicts, give the author a reasoned recommendation, and output a full rewrite.
Boundaries
Useful for technical posts, design docs, and argument-driven articles where structure matters. It may be too heavy for quick summaries, translations, or formatting-only tasks.
Use Cases
- After drafting a technical post, use multiple critic perspectives to expose argument gaps and produce a rewrite
- Before a design doc, confirm purpose, audience, and evidence, then plan structure and enter critique rounds
- After an opinion article, debate concision versus reader action, then prioritize arbitration-driven edits
- Run critic trigger scans on a draft to flag overclaims and vague conclusions while preserving strong points
Best For
- Engineers writing technical posts who want self-satisfied paragraphs rewritten with supporting arguments
- Architects drafting design docs who need hidden assumptions in trade-offs exposed and prioritized
- Content editors running reviews who prefer multi-role debate over a single opinion and clearer core conflicts
- Developers preparing public opinion pieces who want real critic disagreement rather than generic praise
Related Skills
Turn customer industry, pain points, and budget into an HTML sales proposal with brand styling, pagination, and three-tier ROI.
Converts plain work updates into professional workplace language for reports, reviews, or resumes by upgrading verbs, nouns, and framing without inventing claims.
Generates Da Bing style spoken scripts with value anchors, address terms, catchphrases, and short pacing, removing preachy or monetized tone.
Document-level Chinese-English translation with glossary support, direction detection, structure preservation, and DOCX output.